Although separated by 1,000 years, medium, and special effects, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and the hit television series 'Lost' share many themes. The former may not have a smoke monster or involve an airplane crash, and the latter may not have a Green Knight--although with the at-times frivolously intricate and overly obtuse plot lines, anything could have been possible for future seasons. The two do share, however, tests of virtues, hidden human connections and relations, and statuses of being embedded into history and a never-ending timeline.
A test of virtues is common to both Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and 'Lost.' Jack Shepherd, who comes closest out of the ensemble cast to being the protagonist figure of 'Lost', is tested repeatedly just as Sir Gawain is, on his virtues by a force impervious to human intervention. This force in 'Lost' manifests itself in a gamut of intangible ways, sometimes as a visible being such as the enigmatic and frightening smoke monster or immortal and evil Man in Black, but usually as a personal struggle or almost religious and transcendental entity that is beyond not only human control, but also nearly human comprehension. Such a test, or rather series of tests, is placed upon Sir Gawain and his strength of character. It is perpetrated most evidently by Bertilak, of course, but also tacitly by Gawain himself.
The idea of hidden human connections and relations is crucial to both Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and 'Lost.' In 'Lost,' just as in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, identities appear much simpler than they actually are. The revealing of startling family connections in 'Lost'--including but not limited to the true identities of mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, etc.--marked watershed moments in the series. Such is the same in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, in which the reader and Gawain himself realizes that Beatlik is the Green Knight and the Old Lady at the Castle is Morgan La Fluer, or more significantly King Arthur's half-sister and Gawain's own aunt. The revelations in both tales are crucial in connecting the puzzle pieces. This idea of hidden human connections and relationships is further demonstrated by historical ties and links.
Both Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and 'Lost' are embedded into history.
The optimistic essence of the future is present in the ending of both tales. Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, for instance, ends with the following: "Many such, ere we were born,/Have befallen here, ere this./ May He that was crowned with thorn/Bring all men to His bliss! Amen" (Norton, 165). 'Lost' ends with an equally spiritual tone that is forward-looking yet has reverence for the past.
Hey Meggers!
ReplyDeleteThis is really good what you have so far. I do think you should possibly pick a certain character or individual in lost itself and compare it to Sir Gawain or simply compare it to the world that Gawain inhabits. Also, I think you should offer some more quoted information to back up the nice judgements that you have here! And I know it is hard to relay the juiciness of lost through mere text, but I recommend that you elaborate a little more so an unfamiliar reader such as myself can navigate your blog better. Lastly, I am proud of you: your last blog was lacking judgements, but I clearly see here that you have changed that. Good work!
This is a really good concept. I agree with Brandon, maybe focusing on one character from Lost would be more effective, but overall the idea works very well. All of your paragraphs have good topic sentences, and follow your thesis. Some more quotes would probably help support your points. Your final paragraph needs a little more, you don't really explain how Lost ends on a spiritual note. Overall this is a very strong draft, and shouldn't require too much work!
ReplyDeleteHey Megan,
ReplyDeleteThis is really cool so far! I think you have organized everything into a cohesive structure and I like what you've said! For sure, you are going to need to add to the third paragraph evidence, and maybe throw in some quotes, but on top of that I think you might want to increase your analysis--that is, what is significant about these connections? What do similarities say about the intended audience? That way you can add a "so what? to the paper. Looks good so far Meg!